Condominium Owner Evictions Handling a Tough Legal Situation

If a rental tenant defaults, persists in violating rules, or breaks the law, they can be evicted from their unit. It can certainly be a drawn-out, acrimonious process, but it’s more or less routine. While much more rare – and more complicated – it’s also possible to terminate a co-op shareholder’s proprietary lease and compel him or her to vacate the building for compelling financial or administrative reasons. 

By contrast, removing a condo owner from a building or association and effectively wiping out his or her equity position as a member of the community is extremely difficult, and subject to very narrow legal interpretation. For example, while theoretically a co-op shareholder could be evicted from residency for non-monetary defaults, the same is virtually impossible in a condominium. Condos are pure real estate, not shares in a cooperative corporate entity.  As a matter of fact, from a legal standpoint, the word ‘eviction’ cannot be used in reference to removing a condo owner (though it can be applied to removing a rental subtenant in a condominium unit—a point we will return to later.) The closest we can come to a legally recognizable term for this type of action in a condo association is removal.

Removing a Condo Owner

Points of law on this subject are consistent from state to state, with only slight variations. The important distinctions relate to who is being removed; the actual owner of a unit, or that owner’s tenant.  In both cases laws are consistent on the most basic matters, with slightly differing approaches and nuances in some states’ statutes.

Julie Schechter is a partner with Armstrong Teasdale, a law firm based in New York City. She explains that a condominium association, unlike its cooperative corporation cousin, has recourse against a unit owner only for monetary default issues – which in turn almost exclusively refers to non-payment of common charges. Unlike in a co-op, condo owners cannot be removed for bad behavior.  Schechter outlines the process as follows:

“When a condominium is owed common charges [from a unit owner], the board can file a lien against the unit. Once the lien has been filed, the board has two options: it can bring an action to recover the money due, or it can foreclose on the lien.  A lawsuit to recover the money due is less expensive and faster than a lawsuit to foreclose the lien, but neither is very fast.  If the board is successful in a lawsuit to recover the money due, it will obtain a money judgment that can be enforced against the unit owner’s bank accounts or other assets.  The assistance of an enforcement official, such as a City Marshal or Sheriff, is required to enforce the judgment.”


Related Articles

CAI Releases Statement on Foreclosure Moratorium

Calls for 'Flexibility, Understanding, and Business Continuity'

What to Do About HOA Finances & Assessments During Coronavirus

How Associations Should Respond

Removing a Condominium Owner

A Complex Legal Process