Q&A: Comfort Animal

Q.  I live in a 40-unit condo building, which has a no-pets amendment from 1980. A woman purchased a unit and has been seen with a dog, and the dog barks all the time. She signed all the disclosure forms stating ‘no pets, no renters,’ and has given the board a note from a nurse practitioner claiming that the dog is an emotional support animal. What can we do? 

                     — Exasperated Neighbor

A. “The short-answer is that if the resident has all of the proper documentation, you may not be able to do anything, and you may have to allow the dog,” says Matthew W. Gaines, Partner in the Braintree, Massachusetts-based law firm Marcus, Errico, Emmer & Brooks, P.C. “The applicable law is this circumstance is the Federal Fair Housing Act (FFHA). Pursuant to the FFHA, if a disabled resident needs a reasonable accommodation (exception or waiver to a restriction) in order to enjoy the premises, then the board may have to approve the request. That is exactly the situation you are currently facing. 

“This resident is claiming that she has a disability, and that the dog is necessary for her disability. In this case, the resident is asking for an emotional support dog.  You are likely familiar with the term service dog, but emotional support dogs are also recognized under the FFHA. A service dog, as its title implies, provides a service to the disabled person (the most common example of course being a seeing-eye dog). Service dogs are usually professionally trained to provide a service. An emotional support dog, as its title implies, provides emotional support to the disabled resident. Emotional support dogs do not need any special type of training, and can be any type of dog -- or animal, for that matter. Emotional support dogs are typically part of the treatment for a mental disability, as opposed to a physical disability. 

“As for what the board can do – if the disabled resident’s disability is not obvious, which is usually the case with mental/emotional disabilities, the board is entitled to request and receive documentation from a qualified professional (doctor, therapist, psychiatrist, psychologist, social worker, nurse practitioner, etc.) certifying as to the resident’s disability and need for the dog. The board is very limited as to the information you can request. Provided that the professional certifies that the resident is disabled and that the dog is necessary, then the board will almost definitely have to approve the request. 

“In the event the board has to approve the request, the board is entitled to impose reasonable rules and regulations (for example, dog must be on a leash at all times when in the common areas, no excessive barking, etc.).  

“As there can be serious consequences for mishandling a disabled resident’s request for a reasonable accommodation, I would highly recommend that the board get the association’s attorney involved immediately to make sure everything is handled correctly.”

Related Articles

Pet Policies in Boards and Associations

From No Pets to Petopia

Companion Pets and Service Animals

How Do You Determine a Reasonable Accommodation?

Q&A: Seeking Parking Accommodations

Q&A: Seeking Parking Accommodations