Inadequate Reserves The Risks of Not Keeping Up

Inadequate Reserves

There are few feelings worse than encountering an unexpected expense and finding the piggy bank empty. That is why reserve funds and reserve studies are such important elements in the financial well-being of co-ops, condos and homeowners associations. It pays to keep a close eye on those numbers and adhere to the planning available through reserve studies to ensure that when a leaky roof develops or a boiler goes kaput, there will be enough cash on hand to tackle the problem. 

While there’s certainly no shortage of complex financial products and procedures around, the science behind reserve funds and reserve plans is mercifully straightforward, well-tested, and provides an easy-to-follow plan to achieve financial good health. The key is to not abandon the plan, and – for example – tap into the fund for unexpected expenses without an idea of how that deficit will be repaid. In short, your reserve is a piggy bank that should be treated with the utmost care. 

Assessing Needs

When it comes to building a reserve fund, the first step is to hire a professional to conduct a reserve study on your co-op, condo or association community. “For any type of association, condo or co-op, the critical factor is determining what the common assets are,” says Mitchell Frumkin, founder and president of Kipcon, Inc., a New Jersey-based engineering and reserve study firm with offices in Boston. “That’s what the association is responsible for replacing.”

In addition to common elements, the reserve specialist will typically look at projects that will need to be replaced within a 30-year window and that are cyclical in nature, says Russ Fernandes, principal and senior vice president for Becht Engineering BT, Inc., in Basking Ridge, New Jersey. 

“The items will vary depending on the building type,” Fernandes says. “On high-rise buildings, roofs and mechanical equipment are often the largest items included in a reserve fund. For townhouse communities, roofs, siding and asphalt paving are often the largest items included. Other items could include garage roof membranes below a pedestrian or vehicle plaza, common HVAC equipment, and fire protection equipment.” 

To begin putting a study together, the specialist will first go through the Declaration and bylaws to determine common elements and other specifics about the property, says Kevin Bobb, founder of Building Reserves, a reserve firm based in Chicago. “We’ll also meet with the board and manager to see how they are handling things,” he says. “We’ll go through the financials to see how they are currently paying for things. There are a lot of gray areas that have to be defined.”

Once those elements are defined, the specialist will begin the process of quantifying all of the community’s assets. “If it’s the HVAC system, we’ll look at the type of boiler. If it’s the pool, we’ll see what the finishes are. We’ll look at the façade and note whether it’s masonry or vinyl,” Bobb says. “We then look at the condition of the assets, from the condition of the gutters and downspouts to the gutters. We’ll try to determine the ages of everything. So once we do all of that, we have our useful lives for each type of component.”  

Adds Fernandes, “Replacement cost estimates are then calculated for each item. In simplistic terms, the item’s replacement cost is then divided by the remaining life of the item to determine the amount that should be saved each year, so that the money is available when needed. However, the calculation is a little more complicated, in that future costs are estimated utilizing inflation and construction cost indices. Interest earned on existing deposits is also included in the final calculations.”

A reserve study isn’t something that just gets done once and for all. It must be updated periodically to ensure that enough money is being set aside for all contingencies. “Associations need to remember that reserve studies are snapshots in time and need to be updated on a regular basis,” Fernandes says. “Industry standards recommend updates every three to five years to account for such factors as item price increases and changes of the conditions of the items, which could either increase or decrease the life expectancies of the reserve items.”

Says Fernandes, “The key difference between a new study and an update to an existing study is the inventory. Assuming that the item list has not changed, it is not necessary to re-measure and recount the items in the study, which can save an owner some money. However, all of the other procedures described for a new study are also performed when updating an existing study – specifically the condition assessment and cost estimates.” 

Balance at the Ready

According to Bobb, reserve fund reports typically take between four and six weeks to complete after the inspection. Once the study has been completed, the reserve specialist will lay out an action plan for the board and manager. “Once we have all of the data and project set, we prioritize the replacements,” he says. “We make sure [the community] has enough money. The roof is more important than the driveway. The foundation is important. So if they are underfunded, we make sure they have enough money for their financial priorities.” 

Determining how much gets put away into the fund goes back to the root purpose of the reserve. “The concept of reserve funding is a matter of basic fairness,” says Fernandes. “It is a ‘pay as you go’ philosophy. Rather than saving for the purchase of the next roof, for example, the reserve contribution should be considered payment for the use of the present items to date. A condition of underfunded reserves is basically unfair to future homeowners.

“If a unit owner in an underfunded community moves out in year 19, and a special assessment is passed in year 20 to pay for an item or items that were not properly funded in the reserve, that unit owner got away without having to pay their fair share,” continues Fernandes. “The unit owner that buys in year 20 is going to have to pay the special assessment to pay for items that he never got to use.”

Growing the Fund Responsibly

Managing the reserve fund stands as part of a board’s fiduciary responsibilities. And the main goal is to ensure that the fund is always there when needed. “The reserve account is under the direct control of the board of trustees,” says David A. Levy, certified public accountant, in Needham, Massachusetts. “The management of the funds can be managed by the board, or delegated to a professional. It depends on the size of the reserve fund. 

“I would like to think your accountant can advise the board as to how to keep the funds safe and what to steer away from,” he adds. “Not all CPAs are knowledgeable about investments, but all CPAs understand risk and how a board should shy away from too much risk.“

The board should look at the fund as an investment. “Simply, the goal is to preserve, protect, and grow the reserve account to stay in pace with inflation,” Levy explains. “It is not to outperform the S&P. Your owners will be needing the funds that they set aside and they need to be available when the roof starts leaking badly after an  unexpected storm.”

When it comes to investing the reserve fund dollars, “Banks are still the go to place to park association funds,” Levy cautions.“This is done because the board is not taking any risk and wants the FDIC guarantee. It is very safe, but is not keeping up with inflation.  Other safe secure investments that will provide a hedge against inflation are: 1, savings accounts; 2, money market accounts;  3, reward checking accounts (generally pays more than savings or money market);  4, Certificates of Deposit (CDs);  5, Treasury Securities;  6, money market funds; and  7, bond funds (Government Bond Fund).”

The fund also should be managed to accommodate “laddering,” which is when the board staggers the investments so that they come due when they need it three, four or five years out. 

When times are good, it may not hurt to put aside a few extra dollars – although admittedly, this is a rare occurrence. “In my more than 30 years in the industry, I do not believe that I have ever encountered that situation,” says Fernandes. “However, my recommendation would be to put more money away and save for the rainy day. Far too often associations are met with unforeseen emergencies with their infrastructure. Having some extra money in the bank could go a long way toward helping in those situations.”

Keeping the Accounts Full

Underfunded reserves can be a major headache for boards and residents alike. Usually these troubles begin with unexpected expenses, such as a brutal winter when snow removal costs skyrocket and there are simply no other funds to cover the costs. 

In troubled times, some boards will turn to their reserve fund as a source from which they can borrow to patch other holes in the budget. “The board will evaluate if it’s better to borrow from reserve fund versus the bank,” says Frumkin. If they know they can pay the money back, then it may be worth it to avoid the interest rates on a bank loan. 

These days, it is in the best interest of the building to maintain a steady, robust balance in the reserve funds, not only to ensure that all repairs can be made when necessary but also for the financial health of the building or community. Today, a number of financial institutions, including Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, require that a condo or association are putting away a certain percentage of their revenue every year to ensure a healthy reserve fund. “There are pretty strict guidelines and in order to provide financing (for the purchase of new units), they have to be setting aside at least 10 percent each year or have had a reserve study in the last 24 months,” says Frumkin. 

In short, it pays to keep a close eye on all aspects of the reserve fund, from the initial study to the investment plan to the updates. A healthy fund ensures no ugly surprises for residents or shareholders and ensures, too, good financial health for the building or community as a whole. And that’s good news for everyone.      

Liz Lent is a freelance writer and longtime contributor to New England Condominium. 

Related Articles

house building or reconstruction project in rolled paper, flat vector illustration

Capital Design Projects

There’s Always Room for Improvement

Bag with dollar symbol and protection shield. Concept security of money, guaranteed deposits. Client rights protection. Compensation for losses in inflation, safeguarded investment capital.

Financial, Physical, & Operational Health

How Does Your Association Measure Up?

cracked and bandaged piggy bank with one dollar bill inside it

Financial, Physical, & Operational Health

How Does Your Association Measure Up?

Wooden houses with yellow arrows up. housing boom, property market growing, high demand for real estate, house prices rising concept

Insurance Premiums Skyrocket

90% of Multifamily Communities Report Paying More - What's to Blame?

Cracked brick wall with a red house drawn on it -concept image

Façade Inspections

A Critical Component of Your Maintenance Plan

Tapping Reserves in a Time of Financial Crisis

Tapping Reserves in a Time of Financial Crisis

An Option to (Carefully!) Consider