Everybody sometimes disagrees with the decisions of the condo or HOA board. Maybe the choice to rearrange the garbage receptacles out front seems ridiculous, or the ongoing clattering of machinery on the roof is driving the top-floor residents nuts, and the board seems determined to let it fix itself. These are the kinds of inevitable complaints that every board has to deal with sooner or later, and most manage to handle such issues with prudence and aplomb.
But what if the board does things that seem to be beyond the pale—perhaps even illegal? Where do boards’ powers end? While the board is the governing body of the association, there are certain boundaries and limitations that they should operate within.
There are numerous examples across the country of alleged HOA abuse of power from preventing owners to put up political signs or flags or changing the color of their paint trim or window shades. Pets are also a sticking point as this California woman found out: Pamela McMahan didn’t expect her cocker spaniel Ginger to become a problem at a historic condominium building in Long Beach. But she was fined $25 each time she walked her dog through the lobby because HOA rules required all dogs had to be carried. McMahan, an elderly woman who walks with a cane, said she couldn’t carry the dog. She racked up $1,600 in fines and has since moved from the building.
When the Connecticut Condo Owners Coalition conducted a survey of owners, asking about concerns or issues they have with their boards, more than 80 percent complained that their directors “treat owners unfairly and unequally.” Other frequent complaints centered on the conduct of board meetings and board actions to keep owners from seeing or obtaining association documents. The overall results of the survey indicated that owners feel that their association boards tend to overstep their bounds, sometimes to the point of tyranny.
The Law Says
How are a board’s powers spelled out? How do boards know what they can and can’t do under the law? In New England, each state has its specific laws. Take, for example, Massachusetts. “The basic information comes from the Massachusetts statute—although the statute is an enabling statute, meaning that for the most part, it introduces topics and provides condo associations with broad authority, the expectation being that the details get filled in by the association’s condominium documents,” explains attorney Gary Daddario of Perkins & Anctil in Westford, Massachusetts. Each association’s documents provide “more specific explanations and limitations of [statute] powers for the boards, specifically the declaration of trust,” he adds.