Can We Go Green? Check Your Condo Documents Before Launching Green Initiatives

Can We Go Green?

 As gasoline prices rise with increasing summer demand, American thoughts focus  sharply on the cost of energy and ways to trim fat from their overall energy  budgets. Yet for the nation’s nearly sixty million condo dwellers, considering newer energy-saving options  can be a tricky proposition at best. While some condos or co-ops move rapidly to adopt the latest green technologies, many associations, still  governed by documents drafted decades in the past, may be burdened with legal  language that expressly prohibits their communities from making a variety of  environmentally-friendly updates.  

 Has your condo property gone green? And, if not, how green can you go?  

 “I think what you’re seeing is just the beginning of those types of questions arising for [condo]  associations,” says Mitchell Frumkin, president of Kipcon, Inc., a New Jersey-based  engineering and consulting firm that provides condo reserve and transition  studies. “As we go into the future, and people are looking more at the sustainable options  such as solar panels, you’re going to see more of that because it’s affecting the common elements of the community.”  

 Who Owns That Component?

 The problems, experts note, arise from the unique legal aspects of a condo  community. In apartment buildings and similar forms of high-density housing,  property ownership is clearly defined through the traditional landlord/tenant  relationship. Not so with condo properties, and many experienced managers can  speak to the unusual ownership questions that sometimes arise.  

 “Mortgage holders have specific rights,” says New Hampshire attorney Jon Wilkinson, “and for a condominium that wants to make some fairly big changes – whether it’s changing out an HVAC system or installing new utilities that are more energy  efficient – that can potentially impact mortgage holder rights.” Wilkinson, a partner in the Portsmouth-based Wilkinson Law Offices, P.C., works  frequently with green energy development as well as condominium law. “The problem with condominiums is that ownership is not as clear a concept as in  a homeowners association. And when you start having common areas – particularly things like common roof areas or external walls – it’s much more difficult.”  

 “Generally when [condo boards] replace a piece of equipment or roof or something  like that,” says Frumkin, “they don’t really have a problem. They just do it. But when they start changing the  common elements by putting solar panels on roofs and things like that, they may  run into restrictions based on the governing documents.” (While it is true that some condo documents still expressly prohibit solar  panels, this fact is rapidly changing. Nearly all states have addressed solar  rights and easements in recent years, and a number of states – including some in New England – have gone so far as to prohibit language that would limit solar panels.  Condominium properties have been excluded in some cases.)  

 Yet despite some remaining prohibitions, many possibilities exist that would  have little to no impact on community aesthetics. “I have heard of it happening that a covenant or a condo doc might forbid a  photovoltaic array. But that’s not to say that a structure can’t still meet some sort of green criteria,” says Kevin Morrow of the National Association of Home Builders. “As materials wear out, they’re going to need to be replaced. For just about every housing equipment or  building material that exists out there, there’s some greener alternative. That alternative could be trading out the carpet in  your common areas – changing it for carpet that is doing less off-gassing. When you’re repainting your common areas, shop for paints that have less volatile organic  compounds in their vapors.”  

 While Morrow admits some updates – such as changes to carpet and paint – offer no clear economic benefit, many easily-adopted green technologies will  quickly show through on the bottom line. “One that you see a lot of and really goes to help everyone, in the common areas  specifically, is opting for more efficient lighting – doing away with incandescent bulbs in favor of fluorescents bulbs or even  more-efficient LED lighting. That’s something that you see a lot of buildings going to.” The obvious upside, says Morrow, is a shared decrease in a property’s total energy cost. “If you’re landscaping and you opt for landscaping that is less intensive in the terms  of irrigation required, that’s going to obviously decrease the water bill. So there’s an economic benefit as well as an environmental benefit.”  

 Easy Fixes Abound

 But for boards considering more substantial “green” improvements, experts point to many basic structural updates that can be  enacted without risking covenant violation. “When you deal with clubhouses and common area buildings, it’s relatively easy for a community that has a clubhouse…to reduce their energy costs in a few ways—by addressing the mechanical equipment [and] by looking at the building  envelope,” says Frumkin. “And when I’m talking about the building envelope, I’m talking about the walls, the outside walls, the roof, the foundation, that  type of thing. It’s pretty much a proven fact that on any type of building, if you do some  relatively inexpensive upgrades to the building envelope, you can generally  save in the range of 15 or more percent in energy costs.”  

 “I think the key to making the decisions about what to do, as with all things, is  going to lie in what the goals are. You can make any building more efficient,  and frankly, the older a building is, the easier it is to make it operate  better,” says Morrow, who serves as senior project manager for NAHB’s Green Buildings division.  

 Easier still, say experts, in some areas cutting energy costs could be as simple  as flipping a switch – by making a switch to deregulated energy. “Massachusetts will be switching to deregulated energy in the next few months,” notes Frumkin. “Connecticut is deregulated. In most instances, when your homeowners change over  their energy to a deregulated source, they’re probably going to save between eight and 10 percent on their energy costs.  And if the community changes over the energy supply for their common area  clubhouses, they can generally save about 15% of their energy costs by just  switching to deregulated energy. Talk about low-hanging fruit!”  

 “The problem,” says Wilkinson, “is that condo associations, in general, don’t like to stick their necks out. One of the challenges with green building and  energy efficient components is that there is a whole new wave of products and a  lot of great new technology. The challenge is that many of those products have  not been time-tested and we still don’t know about many of them in terms of long term reliability and maintenance  costs. And as a result, I think condo associations, which are very sensitive to  long term capital costs, have not been at the forefront of really trying to  implement those types of energy efficient products.”  

 “I’m not aware of great example in New England where an association has taken very  broad steps to implement energy efficiency technology,” Wilkinson notes.  

 And that, says Kipcon’s Frumkin, is a fundamental mistake. “And I think the big, big mistake associations make is that they don’t do common area upgrades because…you can get unbelievable pricing for capital replacement work by some of the  best contractors due to the economic conditions. They’re looking for work.Most of them have been accumulating reserve funds  irrespective of the economy, and that money is there to be spent and now is the  time to spend it for a number of different reasons – the cost, the quality of the contractors, and the fact that they can  significantly help the economy by doing this at this point.”  

 “For community associations, there are huge opportunities for turning their  communities green,” he says. “In my mind, the opportunities for community associations are much more  significant than the normal world.”  

 Matthew Worley is a freelance writer and a frequent contributor to New England  Condominium.


Related Articles

Garbage sorting and recycle background with color trash bins. Organic, paper, plastic, metal and glass sorting. Reduce reuse recycle slogan.

Recycle, Reuse, Reduce

How Multifamily Communities Can Help Slow Climate Change

Smart house system programming software. Engineering development of building construction, communication, electricity. Design in CAD programs of Smart building. AI of IOT. Architectural 3d plan.

Futurizing Multifamily Buildings

New Materials, Standards, & Designs

CO2 emission reduction concept in hand with environmental icons, global warming, sustainable development, connectivity and renewable energy green business background.

Sustainability in Multifamily Buildings

Balancing Benefits & Budgetary Constraints

Diverse people from all over the world standing together and supporting a sustainable lifestyle: environmental care and eco friendly solutions concept

Simple Ways Co-ops, Condos, & HOAs Can Help the Environment

Small Investment, Big Impact

Climate Legislation and Emissions Issues

Climate Legislation and Emissions Issues

How Attorneys Can Advise Boards

Multifamily Energy Savings Solutions

Multifamily Energy Savings Solutions

Part 2: The Bigger Picture